NRI PULSE STAFF REPORT
Phoenix/Washington, October 2, 2025: Arizona Republican state representative John Gillette is facing widespread condemnation after posting on social media that U.S. Congresswoman Pramila Jayapal “should be tried, convicted, and hanged.” The comment, made on September 25 on X (formerly Twitter), drew immediate outrage from lawmakers, civil rights groups, and political observers, who called it a dangerous escalation of violent political rhetoric.
Gillette’s post was in response to a short clip from Jayapal’s “Resistance Lab” series, which he claimed showed her advocating for the overthrow of the U.S. government. However, the full video, according to multiple outlets including The Guardian, focused on nonviolent protest and civil disobedience, not an armed revolt.
Following backlash, Gillette issued a statement denying that his comment was meant to be taken literally. He said he was referencing existing federal penalties for treason and insurrection, and that anyone who “openly advocates for the violent overthrow of the American government” should face legal consequences. “That is not my invention; it is established law,” he said, insisting his statement was being misrepresented.
Jayapal, a Democrat from Washington and chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, called Gillette’s post “appalling, unacceptable, and dangerous,” adding that such threats endanger lawmakers and discourage peaceful dissent. In a statement, she said, “This is not just about me — this is about protecting democracy from intimidation and violence.”
National Democratic leaders, including House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, urged Arizona’s Republican leadership to condemn the statement and consider disciplinary action. State Democrats have called for Gillette’s expulsion from the Arizona Legislature, arguing that his post violated ethical standards and promoted political violence.
The Communications Workers of America (CWA) union also released a statement supporting Jayapal and condemning threats against nonviolent activists, saying, “CWA members will not be intimidated by those who seek to silence peaceful protest.”
Legal experts note that while free speech protections are broad, explicit calls for violence or execution of public officials can cross into territory unprotected by the First Amendment. Federal law defines treason and insurrection narrowly, and the death penalty is not prescribed for peaceful advocacy or protest.
Gillette, who represents parts of Mohave County, has previously drawn controversy for defending January 6 defendants and making inflammatory remarks about immigrants and religious minorities.
As of press time, no formal disciplinary or legal action had been announced against Gillette. Lawmakers and watchdog groups, however, continue to call for accountability, warning that unchecked threats could further erode public trust in democratic institutions.
Cover image credits: Pramila Jayapal/NRIPulse. John Gillette/www.azleg.gov.
